Gas vs. diesel vs. electric work vehicles: Which is right for your business?

2023 Chevrolet work vehicle on a road

Choosing a vehicle fuel type for your company fleet 

You may have noticed that more businesses are adopting electric vehicles, but is electric power right for you? Keep reading below to compare gas vs. diesel vs. electric work vehicles with Carl Black Orlando and learn about choosing a vehicle fuel type for your company fleet. Once you know which is right for your business, visit us in Orlando, FL, to finance your fleet. 

Work truck lifespanWork truck customization

The benefits of an electric vehicle fleet 

Electric vehicles (EVs) have gained popularity among businesses for several compelling reasons. Here are some key benefits to consider when contemplating an electric vehicle fleet for your company: 

  • Environmental impact: One of the primary advantages of electric vehicles is their reduced environmental impact. EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, contributing to cleaner air and a smaller carbon footprint for your company. 
  • Cost savings: Over the long term, electric vehicles can lead to significant cost savings. They generally have lower maintenance costs and are often more energy-efficient, resulting in lower operational expenses compared to traditional gas or diesel vehicles. 
  • Government incentives: Many governments offer incentives and subsidies for companies adopting electric vehicles. These can include tax credits, grants, and other financial perks, making the transition to an electric fleet more economically viable. 
  • Brand image: Embracing electric vehicles can enhance your company’s image as an environmentally responsible and forward-thinking business. This positive association can be a valuable asset in attracting environmentally conscious customers and employees. 

The challenges of adopting electric vehicles 

While electric vehicles offer numerous advantages, there are also challenges associated with their adoption. It’s essential to be aware of these factors to make an informed decision for your company fleet: 

  • Initial costs: Electric vehicles often have a higher upfront cost than traditional gas or diesel vehicles. While this cost difference is gradually decreasing, it remains a consideration for businesses looking to make the switch. 
  • Charging infrastructure: The availability and accessibility of charging infrastructure can be a concern, especially in regions with limited charging stations. Planning routes and ensuring access to charging points are crucial aspects of managing an electric vehicle fleet. 
  • Range anxiety: Some employees may experience range anxiety, fearing that the electric vehicle’s battery will run out before reaching the destination. Addressing this concern involves educating drivers about the vehicle’s range and optimizing routes accordingly. 
  • Charging time: While charging technology is improving, the charging time for electric vehicles is still longer than refueling with gasoline or diesel. Businesses need to factor in charging times when planning operations and schedules. 

How gas and diesel vehicles compare  

Gasoline and diesel vehicles have been the traditional choices for company fleets. Understanding the comparison between these two fuel types can help in making an informed decision: 

  • Fuel efficiency: Diesel vehicles generally have higher fuel efficiency than gasoline vehicles. They can cover more miles per gallon, making them a cost-effective choice for long-haul transportation. 
  • Initial cost: Gasoline vehicles typically have a lower upfront cost than diesel vehicles. This can be a significant factor for businesses looking to minimize initial expenses. 
  • Maintenance costs: Diesel engines often require more maintenance than gasoline engines. While diesel engines can be more durable, their maintenance costs can increase over the vehicle’s lifespan. 
  • Emissions: Diesel vehicles produce more nitrogen oxides and particulate matter than gasoline vehicles. Gasoline engines are generally considered cleaner in terms of emissions. 

Table comparing fuel types for your fleet 

This table provides a comprehensive overview of factors to consider when choosing a fuel type for your company fleet, allowing you to make an informed decision based on your specific needs and priorities. 

Factor  Electric Vehicles  Gasoline Vehicles  Diesel Vehicles 
Environmental Impact  Zero tailpipe emissions  Emissions produced  Emissions produced 
Cost Savings  Lower operational costs over time  Lower upfront costs  Higher fuel efficiency 
Government Incentives  Potential for tax credits and grants  Varies by region  Varies by region 
Brand Image  Positive environmental image  Neutral or varies  Neutral or varies 
Dependence on Fossil Fuels  Reduced dependence  Reliant on fossil fuels  Reliant on fossil fuels 
Initial Costs  Higher upfront costs  Lower upfront costs  Higher upfront costs 
Charging Time  Longer charging times  Not applicable  Not applicable 
Fuel Efficiency  Not applicable  Lower than diesel  Higher than gasoline 
Maintenance Costs  Generally lower  Lower than diesel, higher than electric  Higher than gasoline 

Chevrolet work trucksGMC work trucks

2023 GM work truck side view

2023 GM work vehicle with a man leaning on the tailgate